Second reading of Bill C-241, An Act to establish a national strategy respecting flood and drought forecasting

By: The Hon. Tracy Muggli

Share this post:

Parliament Hill from across the Ottawa River, Ottawa

Hon. Tracy Muggli: Honourable senators, I rise today to speak to Bill C-241, An Act to establish a national strategy respecting flood and drought forecasting. This is the first bill I am sponsoring in the Senate of Canada, and I couldn’t be more proud, as this legislation presents a great opportunity to help support Canadians and our economy through a better understanding of our changing environment.

Bill C-241, which was introduced by member of Parliament Tatiana Auguste in the other place, seeks to establish a national strategy for flood and drought forecasting. Tatiana, as you may recall, is the Liberal MP for Terrebonne. She introduced this legislation in the fall of 2025 and oversaw its movement to committee in the House before her election win was annulled by the Supreme Court.

Then she was forced to rerun for her seat in a by-election, which she won, before returning to expertly steer this legislation through third reading. She did all this in just over a year.

This legislation enjoyed significant support in the other place, with 303 MPs voting in favour, including members of the Liberals, the Conservative Party, the NDP and the Greens. I too am proud to stand in support of this bill. As floods, droughts and wildfires continue to dominate our headlines, I hope you too will support this worthy legislation.

Canada remains the only G7 country without a nationally coordinated system for flood forecasting. While it may come as a surprise to many, the most expensive natural disasters that Canada faces are floods. And as someone from Saskatchewan, we know all too well the harmful impacts drought has on the agriculture sector of the economy and those who work in agriculture.

Canada has some of the world’s largest river systems and water reserves, and we also have some of the most respected hydrologists, water researchers and scientific institutions. I have brought up the work of Dr. John Pomeroy before in this chamber, and you will hear me quote him again today. Dr. Pomeroy is a world-renowned hydrologist, the Director of the Global Water Futures program and a professor at the University of Saskatchewan. He has played an integral role in the development of this bill.

While we have respected experts and institutions across Canada, forecasting of floods and droughts remains fragmented and carried out in silos by provinces, territories, municipalities and even regional conservation authorities. This approach addresses regionally specific challenges but makes it impossible to integrate data for weather forecasting and emergency management. It means inconsistent resource levels and some duplication of services, especially in our many transboundary rivers.

Those silos mean that forecasting, data collection and even the technology being employed change from one place to the next. It means slower adaptation to new technologies and best practices. And it results in a lack of coordination and an abundance of incompatibility across these many actors and federal agencies.

This legislation sets out to provide these many stakeholders with the information and tools they need to coordinate and communicate and, in turn, improve forecasting, better understand risks and minimize the impacts of flood and drought events.

An example of this is the Yukon Territory. For nearly a decade, Dr. John Pomeroy, alongside research assistants, has been helping with flood forecasting in the Yukon River and Porcupine River basins. During this process, initially supported by Global Water Futures and Environment and Climate Change Canada, the Yukon flood forecasting system was developed. However, a lack of financial resources and expiring operating grants from Yukon Environment and NSERC mean this is the last winter they will have the funds to hire researchers to do this work.

It should come as no surprise that provinces and jurisdictions with smaller populations don’t have the resources and expertise to adequately forecast. But I think you’ll agree that Canadians from coast to coast to coast deserve the chance to be prepared.

And with ongoing climate change, we have a lot to prepare for. We have seen the consequences of drought in the Prairies. The drought of 2001 and 2002 resulted in an estimated $3.6-billion decline in agricultural production nationally over those two years.

More recently, the 2021 drought across Western Canada saw total crop production fall by approximately 44% compared with the previous year. For producers experiencing drought, it means watching a year of crops die out and wondering how to keep a family farm financially viable.

The data envisioned in this legislation won’t prevent drought, but it will help farmers make difficult decisions about what crops to plant and how to move forward by reducing uncertainty.

The effects of these disasters are widespread, and they create real human impacts. I’ve experienced that stress. Those formative experiences on a farm in Saskatchewan during the drought in 1988 are part of what drew me to sponsoring this bill. These are experiences that stay with people and cause lasting harm.

The Saskatchewan Farm Stress Line was established in 1992 to provide confidential support and crisis counselling to people in the agriculture sector. Reporting from the former executive director indicated that calls had increased by 500% between 2012 and 2020. In fact, the summer of 2021 saw record call volumes. That was also a year of intense drought in Saskatchewan.

When a producer loses a crop, the impact can extend well beyond that season. It affects financial security and mental health and puts their livelihood and connection to their culture in jeopardy.

Better forecasting means more time to make informed decisions. On the farm, that means taking the power back to make decisions about water management, crops suited for conditions and livestock management — preparation instead of crisis response.

This legislation deals with both flood and drought forecasting, and each brings with them an array of challenges.

In 2023, British Columbia experienced significant drought conditions in 80% of the province by mid-August. Water restrictions were introduced, emergency measures were taken, and these conditions led to a record wildfire season in the province. While drought has a particularly significant impact on agricultural production and rural communities, flooding presents another serious threat to communities across Canada.

In 2013, flooding in southern Alberta caused widespread devastation, particularly in Calgary and surrounding communities. Approximately 100,000 people were evacuated that year, mainly in Alberta, but downriver flooding also impacted folks in Saskatchewan and Manitoba. Tragically, five people died.

More than 2,000 members of the Canadian Armed Forces were deployed in southern Alberta. Flood forecasts and alerts for Canmore and High River were issued hours after evacuations had already begun. The financial cost in losses and reparations reached between $5 billion and $6 billion.

In 2019, flooding along the Ottawa River affected communities in Ontario and Quebec. Thousands of homes were flooded, and hundreds of people were displaced. We also saw flooding in New Brunswick along the Saint John River that year.

In 2021, British Columbia experienced devastating flooding that resulted in more than 18,000 people being evacuated. Major highways and economic supply chains were disrupted, with over 20,000 hectares of farmland damaged. More than 50 First Nations communities were affected. The federal government ultimately committed more than $1 billion in direct disaster recovery funding with total costs estimated at over $10 billion.

Just last week, British Columbia experienced another round of serious flooding. Heavy rainfall caused rivers in the Pemberton Valley to overflow, flooding properties and prompting evacuation orders and alerts.

Colleagues, if you were paying attention, you’ll have noticed that since 2013, nearly every province across this country has been affected by severe flooding and drought, costing tens of billions of dollars. These examples demonstrate that flooding does not respect provincial boundaries. Rivers flow across jurisdictions, and the impacts of extreme weather can quickly spread from one community or region to another.

This underscores the importance of reliable information that can be shared widely and made available before a crisis.

Communities need to know what is coming and how much time they have to respond. That information can make the difference between an orderly evacuation and a dangerous emergency. It can help municipalities protect critical infrastructure and residents make decisions to protect their families and property.

The economic consequences of these events are also becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

Blair Feltmate, who leads the Intact Centre on Climate Adaptation at the University of Waterloo, has written about the growing financial consequences of extreme weather in Canada.

Between 1983 and 2008, catastrophic insured losses in Canada generally ranged between $250 million and $450 million annually. Since 2009, those losses have grown substantially. In 2024, insured catastrophic losses reached a record level of approximately $8.5 billion. That year alone included major flooding in Toronto and southern Ontario and significant flooding in Quebec, as well as the Jasper wildfire.

Mr. Feltmate has also pointed to the growing challenge of obtaining insurance coverage for basement flooding, with an estimated 1.5 million Canadian homeowners no longer able to obtain that coverage. This can also create challenges in acquiring a mortgage.

The cost of extreme weather is not borne by one level of government or one sector of the economy. It is borne by all of us. Knowing more about where risks may exist and how water systems are changing and sharing data and expertise are the keys to keeping up with a rapidly changing environment.

This is where I believe Bill C-241 can make an important contribution. This legislation requires the government to work with partners to assess existing capabilities and consider opportunities for improvement in the development of a national strategy. It also requires the strategy to be reported to Parliament within two years, with a further review of its effectiveness five years after the report to Parliament.

Colleagues, I want to address something that I think is important when discussing the role of the federal government in this area. A national strategy should not be about taking responsibility away from provinces, territories and Indigenous groups; nor should it be about creating another layer of bureaucracy or duplicating work that is already being done.

In fact, one of the concerns with our current approach is that duplication is already occurring because of the fragmented way in which forecasting services have developed.

The flooding from 2013 that I mentioned earlier started in the Rockies in British Columbia and affected all provinces east to Manitoba.

Where rivers cross provincial boundaries, jurisdictions are collecting similar information, developing separate models and maintaining separate forecasting systems. There are opportunities to improve how that information is shared and how resources are coordinated.

The federal government has an important role to play in bringing these efforts together, and Bill C-241 is the pathway to making that work a success.

When I spoke with the Saskatchewan Water Security Agency, they told me that, in a national strategy, the federal government is well suited to act as a coordinator and facilitator. They said that the goal should be to support the work already being done by provincial and territorial partners, to help make information more accessible and actionable and to avoid creating unnecessary administrative burdens.

They also said that practical opportunities to make better use of federal resources exist. For example, they suggested coordinated procurement of certain technologies to reduce costs.

Importantly, this work is focused on applied research. We need to fund research and share answers to practical questions to give decision makers information they can interpret and use. We also need to recognize that our ability to forecast and prepare for these events is becoming more important as climate changes. As I mentioned recently in the chamber when former Irish president Mary Robinson was here, the earth has now hit the tipping point of 1.5 degrees Celsius of warming from pre-industrial temperatures.

Canada is warming almost twice as fast as the global rate, and the Arctic is warming even faster.

John Pomeroy, who has played an important role in developing this legislation, recently spoke to The Globe and Mail about the rapid retreat of glaciers and the consequences for Canada’s water systems.

He pointed to Peyto Glacier in the Canadian Rockies. It has retreated more than half a kilometre in just five years. As glaciers shrink and snowpacks decline, Canada faces growing risks to its water supply and water quality, along with changing conditions that can increase the likelihood of flooding, drought and wildfires.

These changes have significant economic, social and environmental consequences, particularly for communities that depend on reliable water sources.

Across Canada, we are experiencing more frequent and severe extreme weather events, and we need to be better prepared for the interconnected nature of these risks. I was reminded of this during many discussions on climate adaptation at COP 31, where adaptation is a key pillar of negotiation. We often talk about the need to respond to climate change, but we also need to talk about how we prepare for the impacts that are already being felt by communities across the country. Adaptation is now required. That means investing in better information, better planning and better coordination.

As MP Auguste mentioned in her second reading speech in the other place:

This bill is not only a preventive measure, but it also protects human life, as well as our planet and future generations.

She continued, saying:

. . . this bill will enable effective coordination between the provinces and territories, indigenous peoples and experts. This is about creating a table where everyone can sit down and work together for the good of our country.

That is what Bill C-241 can help lead to.

It also means recognizing the value of Canadian research and expertise. The University of Saskatchewan is a particularly good example of the kind of expertise we have right here at home. In the 2026 ShanghaiRanking of water resources disciplines, the University of Saskatchewan ranked first in Canada and among the top 10 institutions globally.

John Pomeroy has helped build an extensive network of water research and monitoring expertise through the Centre for Hydrology and the Global Water Futures Observatories. This work brings together researchers from universities across the country and provides an important foundation for understanding Canada’s water systems.

These researchers have been asking for a nationally coordinated forecasting strategy for years. We should be proud of the fact that this level of expertise exists in Canada, but we should also be listening to it. This is also an opportunity to build on work already being done in other areas of climate preparedness.

For example, the Agriculture and Forestry Committee’s Canada on Fire report from earlier this year recommended using the same data for flood and drought forecasting to improve wildfire hazard mapping.

There is a clear connection between that work and the goals of Bill C-241. Better information about drought conditions, water availability and flood risks can also contribute to our understanding of wildfire hazards and the changing risks facing communities.

Colleagues, this is not just a Canadian challenge.

At COP 31 in Türkiye this past week, Canada was taking part in discussions about financing and expanding climate risk and early warning systems, particularly in the least developed countries and small island developing states. I was very happy to see the government announce that it intends to contribute up to $10 million to an international initiative to strengthen climate risk forecasting and early warning systems.

The international Climate Risk and Early Warning Systems, or CREWS, initiative, launched at COP 21 in Paris, recognizes that early warning information can save lives and protect communities, particularly in places where the resources and infrastructure to respond to extreme weather are limited. It is important that Canada continues to support these international efforts, and we should also recognize that the need for better forecasting and preparedness exists here at home. The purpose of Bill C-241 is straightforward. It is about establishing a national strategy that brings together the expertise, information, stakeholders and resources needed to improve flood and drought forecasting in Canada. It is about giving communities more time to prepare and adapt, giving producers better information to make decisions, helping governments plan for future risks and reducing the economic and human costs of extreme weather.

We cannot control the weather, and we cannot stop every flood or prevent every drought. But we can control how prepared we are. We can choose to be more proactive rather than reactive. We can make better use of the expertise and resources we already have, and we can choose to work together across jurisdictions to make sure that Canadians have useful information that they need before disaster strikes.

Colleagues, I encourage you to support sending Bill C-241 to committee for further study.

Thank you. Marsee. Meegwetch.

Share this post: